The Formation of the Modern Political Subject: Factors and Consequences of Bread Riots in the Naseri Period and a Critique of Conventional Historiography

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

PhD in Political Sociology, Allameh Tabatabaei University

Abstract
This study focuses on historical moments neglected by conventional historiography, particularly bread riots during the Naseri era (1227–1274 AH/1848–1896 CE), triggered by economic crises like famine and bread shortages. Orientalist narratives often dismiss these uprisings as mere hunger-driven outbursts with negligible historical impact. However, their persistence, diverse social coalitions, and significant socio-political consequences necessitate re-examination. This research investigates: the causes of these riots, the social groups involved, and their broader outcomes. Drawing on E.P. Thompson’s moral economy and Edmund Burke’s social history frameworks, we analyze concepts such as justice-seeking, the clergy’s pivotal role, the participation of diverse social strata, and the resultant political and social transformations. Employing a historical-documentary method, findings indicate that the riots were driven by famine, rulers’ mismanagement, Islamic cultural values, and justice-oriented traditions. Key outcomes include organized uprisings through alliances among women, lutis, clergy, and lower classes, the establishment of popular councils and associations, shifts in local governance, and the emergence of heightened political consciousness. These protests laid critical groundwork for the modern political subject, challenging simplistic interpretations and highlighting their role in shaping Iran’s socio-political evolution.

Keywords

Subjects


Bibliography
- Adamiyat, Feridun and Nateq, Homa. (1356). Social, Political, and Economic Thoughts in - Unpublished Works of the Qajar Era. Tehran: Agah. [in Persian]
- Adamiyat, Feridun. (1385). The Idea of Progress and the Rule of Law in the Era of Sepahsalar. Tehran: Kharazmi, 3rd ed. [in Persian]
- Alam Dari, Farhad. (1390). Iranian Food and Table Setting in the Qajar Period. Tehran: Simin. [in Persian]
- Algar, Hamid. (1369). Religion and State in Iran, translated by Abolqasem Seri. Tehran: Tus. [in Persian]
- Amanat, Abbas. (1383). Pivot of the Universe: Nasser al-Din Shah Qajar and the Monarchy of Iran, translated by Hasan Kamshad. Tehran: Karnameh. [in Persian]
- Burke, E. (1986). Understanding Arab Protest Movements. Arab Studies Quarterly, 8(4), 333-345. Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org/stable/41857851
- Brugsch, Heinrich. (1373). A Journey to the Court of the Sultan Owner of the Age, Vols. 1-2, translated by Hossein Kordbacheh. Tehran: Elmi va Farhangi. [in Persian]
- Cronin, Stephanie. (1394). The Constitutional Revolution, Populist Politics, and State-Building in Iran. In Majmu'eh-ye Maqalat-e Enqelab-e Mashruteh-ye Iran, edited by Vanessa Martin and Hushang Shahabi, translated by Mohammad Ebrahim Fattahi. Tehran: Ketab-e Parseh, pp. 200-175. [in Persian]
- Foran, John. (1392). Fragile Resistance, translated by Ahmad Tadayyon. Tehran: Mo'asseseh-ye Khadamat-e Farhangi-ye Rasa, 12th ed. [in Persian]
- Fouzi, Yahya. (1393). Justice in Islamic Political Thought: Conceptualization and Strategies. Faslenameh-ye Andisheh-ye Siyasi dar Islam, Autumn 1393, No. 1, pp. 90-59. [in Persian]
- Habl al-Matin Newspaper. (1313). No. 10, Year 4, 12 Ramadan 1313. [in Persian]
- Habl al-Matin Newspaper. (1313). No. 10, Year 4, 21 Sha'ban 1313. [in Persian]
- Husseini, Robab. (1371). Famine and Inflation in the Years 1287 and 1288. Ganjineh-ye Asnad, Nos. 7 and 8, pp. 63-47. [in Persian]
- Jamalzadeh, Mohammad Ali. (1376). The Worthy Treasure. Tehran: Bunyad-e Moqofat-e Doktor Mahmud Afshar. [in Persian]
- Lapidus, Ira. (1391). Islam and the Historical Experience of Muslim Nations, translated by Abbas Ahmadvand. Ketab-e Mah-Tarikh va Joghrafia-Nazargah, No. 176, pp. 19-12. [in Persian]
- Martin, Vanessa. (1394). The Qajar Era: Bargaining, Protest, and the State in Nineteenth-Century Iran, translated by Afsaneh Monfared. Tehran: Akhtaran, 2nd ed. [in Persian]
- Mirkiaei, Mehdi. (1394). Bread and Politics. Tehran: Nashr-e Elm. [in Persian]
- Mostowfi, Hamdollah. (1393). My Life Story. Tehran: Zavar, Vol. 1. [in Persian]
- Okazoki, Shuko. (1365). The Great Famine of 1288. Ayandeh, Year 12, pp. 41-28. [in Persian]
- Rahmanian, Dariush and Mirkiaei, Mehdi. (1392). The Impact of Bread Riots on Government-People Relations in the Naseri Era. Tahqiqat-e Tarikh-e Ejtema'i, Winter 1392, No. 2, pp. 97-65. [in Persian]
- Rahmanian, Dariush and Mirkiaei, Mehdi. (1393). The Impact of Drought and Famine on Land Ownership in Naseri Era Iran. Motale'at-e Tarikh-e Islam, No. 23, pp. 253-219. [in Persian]
- Sa'idi Sirjani, Ali Akbar. (1361). Daily Events. Tehran: Amirkabir, 2nd ed. [in Persian]
- Said, Edward. (1383). Orientalism, translated by Lotfali Khonji. Tehran: Amirkabir. [in Persian]
- Sardar, Zia al-Din. (1387). Orientalism, translated by Mohammad Ali Qasemi. Tehran: Pazhuheshkadeh-ye Motale'at-e Farhangi va Ejtema'i. [in Persian]
- Sinki, Majd al-Molk. (1358). The Majdiyeh Treatise, edited by Fadlollah Gorgani. Tehran: Eqbal. [in Persian]
- Thompson, E. P. (1971). The moral economy of the English crowd in the eighteenth century. Past & present, (50), 76-136.
- Wills, C.J. (1368). Iran a Century Ago, translated by Gholamhossein Qaragozlu. Tehran: Eqbal. [in Persian]
- Zel al-Soltan, Mas'ud Mirza. (1368). Memoirs of Zol al-Soltan, edited by Khadijeh Jam. Tehran: Asatir, Vol. 2. [in Persian]

  • Receive Date 24 July 2025
  • Revise Date 15 October 2025
  • Accept Date 18 October 2025